Relaxed friendly staff, great to have the tavern and bar downstairs, spacious rooms. LOVE Malik & Goetz bathroom products 😍

Stayed in March 2025

The front desk was not very friendly or welcoming . Some were but 90% of our stay we didn’t feel welcomed.

The space in both rooms was great. The facilities were clean.

Stayed in January 2025

The entrance is small.

Good location.

Stayed in January 2025

carpets and some furniture looked stained/worn.

Stayed in March 2025

Very dirty, very cold. There is no kettle in the room, no tea, no cups, no slippers. I do not know what the $8 was charged for. They were not in the receipt at check-out.

Friendly staff

Stayed in December 2024

Noise from the plumbing, flushing a toilet or running the shower was quite noisy and could be heard from neighbouring rooms. It wasn't explained at check-in how the included breakfast process works. I had to seek details to understand, it is not obvious.

Very decent sized room, comfortable bed and nice bathroom/shower. The hotel toiletries are great.

Stayed in February 2025

Staff was beyond helpful and kind except for the manager. He should not be permitted to work directly with guests.

Stayed in December 2024

All good

Stayed there 4 times , Clean spacious

Stayed in December 2024

I booked a queen terrace room and the terrace was covered in scaffolding so the terrace was completely unusable- couldn’t even open the door as the scaffolding was in the way. This was disappointing as I wanted to be able to be out there to drink coffee and watch the city.

Clean rooms in a great location. Easy to access subway. Friendly staff.

Stayed in February 2025

The traffic noise was constant day and night

The location in Downtown Manhattan was exactly what I wanted. I could visit the 9/11 museum, the World Trade Center, and Wall Street within a few minutes. The staff is excellent and great with recommendations.

Stayed in January 2025

Nothing.

Clean. Not over crowded. Homey. Beautifully designed. Reasonably priced. I’ve traveled to NYC several times for work and the issue with most hotels is that they are always over priced, over crowded, and too expensive. Smyth Tribeca was special in that it was none of these things. I will come back 100%

Stayed in January 2025

I received an unexpected charge on my account for a charitable donation that I did not authorize. Although the staff reversed it (not very graciously) when I complained, it should never have been charged in the first place. If I want to make a charitable donation, I will. If the hotel asks if I wish to make one, I can say yes or no. The hotel has no right to charge my card for a donation that I did not authorize.

The room was more spacious than the average New York room and it was nicely appointed, clean and modern.

Stayed in January 2025

Hotel staff were pleasant, but not particularly friendly or everly helpful, which was a little disappointing, given it was the holiday season.

It's in a great location, with super easy access to the subway just outside the hotel. Rooms were very clean and orderly. Nice mini-bar selections too! Great bar and restaurant on premises. Good options nearby for quick breakfast if needed.

Stayed in December 2024

The fan is noisy but that’s just how the US builds houses - a bit noisy compared to Europe. On the invoice they put a charity charge of $ 2 per night which isn’t a problem if someone would have told me upfront but if it’s not agreed on it feels like a small scam. Watch out!

Great proximity to the subway and nice view into the city. Tribeca is less crowded and would really recommend as a location to stay here. Rooms are spacious and clean with a minibar and nice amenities. Front office team is relatively friendly, housekeeping staff is superb.

Stayed in January 2025

Coffee in the room!

Staff is excellent, go out of their way to be helpful

Stayed in December 2024

I liked everything except out house phone in the room was not working. They sent an engineer to fix or replace it with no success. Could not get streaming networks easily on the tv. They had 100 channels including HBO. Ordered an electric kettle for tea and they only had paper to go cups. (That seemed strange since they have a restaurant.

Beautiful decor, if you like modern design and architecture. Clean and comfortable.

Stayed in December 2024

No coffee machine or kettle in the room

Spacious room

Stayed in December 2024

Only downside was the bar in the hotel was out of action for private functions on two evenings of our stay and the restaurant next door was very busy and noisy.

Fantastic stay. Hotel is chic and in a great location. Staff were very helpful and pleasant.

Stayed in December 2024

stronger water pressure in the shower would be nicer, but it's negligible

Great neighborhood, amazing location, 3 subway lines with one significant one (the red line) right at the door of the hotel. A huge room and certainly in the terms of New York and in general, a well-equipped and luxurious room with a huge corner window to the street. We got the room when we arrived, three hours before the check-in time

Stayed in November 2024

Room was smaller than expected, with no place to sit. Balcony was nice, with table and two chairs. Nice place to sit if not too cool. Subway station half a block away.

Adequate gym downstairs. Restaurant on site, with many others nearby. Room was very clean. Staff was very nice.

Stayed in October 2024

Quietness and location

Stayed in October 2024

Some things could be bettered. Some rust on the bathroom soap holder and not enough hooks for towels. There could be more plugs beyond the hard to reach behind the walls ones. The room where we stayed had no art on the walls and it felt a bit sad. A little table close to chair would be great, as well as a coffee maker. For the price these things should be a must.

Comfortable place in Tribeca. Amazing staff, champagne offered at check in. The staff went above and beyond to keep us happy. Beds are Comfortable, quiet rooms.

Stayed in October 2024

The quality of little things like the towel rail is almost ready the fall off and the cubboard doors with the latching are done on the cheap.

Very friendly staff in a good location with subway just as you walk out. Well organised room.

Stayed in September 2024

Just needed a full length mirror in the room

All staff were really helpful from helping with lost luggage to restaurant suggestions and directions! Beds were super comfy and location was fantastic for subways and walking around neighborhoods in Lower Manhattan

Stayed in September 2024